Investigation methodology
Rough
title: ‘How does a child’s language change dependant on who they are
conversing with?’
The data
that I chose to collect is based on child language acquisition. Before
collecting my data there were many factors that I had to consider, including:
- · Reliability
- · Confidentiality
- · Ethicality
- · Comparability
Reliability
was a main factor that I thoroughly considered.
I had to collect enough data so that any unrepresentative aspects do not
seem significant. To do so I:
- · Recorded for the same amount of time (ten minutes)
- · Recorded on the same day, every week for six weeks
As
I was recording the child’s natural speech I had to consider ‘the observer’s
paradox’. This states that people change their speech and behavior as soon as
they know they are being watched/recorded. To ensure that I collected fair
speech, I have only transcribed between four and six minutes of speech leaving
me with six lots of two minutes conversations.
However, the child was not completely aware that I was recording him due
to permission being granted from his parent as he is aged under sixteen.
This
then leads me onto the factor of ethicality. I had to gain informed consent
from the parent of the child, as well as the others that were included in the
recordings through interacting with the child. To do so, I wrote a formal
letter stating my intentions, which was then read through, agreed and signed by
all participants. Informed consent allowed everyone involved to understand why I
was taking these recordings, who will be accessing it and how I will protect
their confidentiality.
Confidentiality
was important to me as I wanted to ensure that everybody knew they could have
an open, random conversation that will be kept anonymous. To do this, I have
changed all names when transcribing the speech, and any personal details have
been changed such as birthdays, addresses etc.
I
am also looking into comparability between the recordings because who the child
is talking to varies between each one. I am going to look at how the child
responds and communicates with the different members of the conversation and
also determine if it’s due to the language and techniques used by the adult.
This is things such as questions and child directed speech. To be comparable, I
took the recordings at approximately the same time every week. This was every
Wednesday evening starting between 6-630 pm. This is to ensure that the speech
was typical of an evening conversation between members of my family.
How his language changes is difficult if you don't have a baseline. Why is he with someone different every time? Have you looked to se if there are common factors in his talk every time? What are you looking at exactly? If more CDS techniques are used, that he talks more or says something more complex? Or if he has a closer relationship, he talks more or more revealingly? How will you leasure the closeness of the relationship or the depth/complexity of his talk? I am not criticising, just wondering/challenging you!
ReplyDelete